Skip Navigation
Skip to contents

Ann Coloproctol : Annals of Coloproctology

OPEN ACCESS
SEARCH
Search

Search

Page Path
HOME > Search
1 "Patients outcomes"
Filter
Filter
Article category
Keywords
Publication year
Authors
Display
Original Article
Comparison of Short-term Surgical Outcomes between a Robotic Colectomy and a Laparoscopic Colectomy during Early Experience
Jin Yong Shin
J Korean Soc Coloproctol. 2012;28(1):19-26.   Published online February 29, 2012
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3393/jksc.2012.28.1.19
  • 7,334 View
  • 59 Download
  • 44 Citations
AbstractAbstract PDF
Purpose

Although robotic surgery was invented to overcome the technical limitations of laparoscopic surgery, the role of a robotic (procto)colectomy (RC) for the treatment of colorectal cancer compared to that of a laparoscopic (procto)colectomy (LC) was not well defined during the initial adoption periods of both procedures. This study aimed to evaluate the efficacy and the safety of a RC for the treatment of colorectal cancer by comparing the authors' initial experiences with both a RC and a LC.

Methods

The first 30 patients treated by using a RC for colorectal cancer from July 2010 to March 2011 were compared with the first 30 patients treated by using a LC for colorectal cancer from December 2006 to June 2007 by the same surgeon. Perioperative variables and short-term outcomes were analyzed. In addition, the 30 RC and the 30 LC cases involved were divided into rectal cancer (n = 17 and n = 12, respectively), left-sided colon cancer (n = 7 and n = 12, respectively) and right-sided colon cancer (n = 6 and n = 6, respectively) for subgroup analyses.

Results

The mean operating times for RC and LC were significantly different at 371.8 and 275.5 minutes, respectively, but other perioperative parameters (rates of open conversion, numbers of retrieved lymph node, estimated blood losses, times to first flatus, maximal pain scores before discharge and postoperative hospital stays) were not significantly different in the two groups. Subgroup analyses showed that the mean operative times for a robotic proctectomy and a laparoscopic proctectomy were 396.5 and 298.8 minutes, respectively (P < 0.000). Postoperative complications occurred in five patients in the RC group and in six patients in the LC group (P = 0.739).

Conclusion

Although the short-term outcomes of a RC during its initial use were better than those of a LC (with the exception of operating time), differences were not found to be significantly different. On the other hand, the longer operation time of a robotic proctectomy compared to that of a laparoscopic proctectomy during the early period may be problematic.

Citations

Citations to this article as recorded by  
  • Evaluation of Robotic Versus Laparoscopic Surgery for Right Colon Cancer Treatment: Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis
    Martina Sardonini, Daniele Giuliani, Alessandro Spizzirri, Vincenzo Napolitano, Roberto Cirocchi, Luca Properzi, Francesco Brucchi, Sara Lauricella, Francesca Pennetti Pennella, Valentina Bartolini, Marco Coccetta
    Journal of Clinical Medicine.2026; 15(4): 1493.     CrossRef
  • Comparison of Operative Time Between Robotic and Laparoscopic Low Anterior Resection for Rectal Cancer:A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis
    Zhen Chen, Hua Yu, Huaping Wu, Pingxi Wang, Fanwei Zeng
    Surgical Innovation.2023; 30(3): 390.     CrossRef
  • Comparison of robotic right colectomy and laparoscopic right colectomy: a systematic review and meta-analysis
    Jianchun Zheng, Shuai Zhao, Wei Chen, Ming Zhang, Jianxiang Wu
    Techniques in Coloproctology.2023; 27(7): 521.     CrossRef
  • Robotic versus laparoscopic left colectomy: a systematic review and meta-analysis
    Leonardo Solaini, Antonio Bocchino, Andrea Avanzolini, Domenico Annunziata, Davide Cavaliere, Giorgio Ercolani
    International Journal of Colorectal Disease.2022; 37(7): 1497.     CrossRef
  • The Senhance Surgical System in Colorectal Surgery: A Systematic Review
    Tyler McKechnie, Jigish Khamar, Ryan Daniel, Yung Lee, Lily Park, Aristithes G. Doumouras, Dennis Hong, Mohit Bhandari, Cagla Eskicioglu
    Journal of Robotic Surgery.2022; 17(2): 325.     CrossRef
  • Comparison of Robotic and Laparoscopic Colectomies Using the 2019 ACS NSQIP Database
    Sara S. Soliman, Joseph Flanagan, Yun Hsiang Wang, Patricia B. Stopper, Rolando H. Rolandelli, Zoltan H. Nemeth
    Southern Medical Journal.2022; 115(12): 887.     CrossRef
  • Laparoscopic versus robotic right colectomy with extra-corporeal or intra-corporeal anastomosis: a systematic review and meta-analysis
    Pietro Genova, Gianni Pantuso, Calogero Cipolla, Mario Adelfio Latteri, Solafah Abdalla, Jean-Christophe Paquet, Francesco Brunetti, Nicola de’Angelis, Salomone Di Saverio
    Langenbeck's Archives of Surgery.2021; 406(5): 1317.     CrossRef
  • Urological and sexual function after robotic and laparoscopic surgery for rectal cancer: A systematic review, meta‐analysis and meta‐regression
    Ian Jun Yan Wee, Li‐Jen Kuo, James Chi‐Yong Ngu
    The International Journal of Medical Robotics and Computer Assisted Surgery.2021; 17(1): 1.     CrossRef
  • Comparison of clinical efficacy of robotic right colectomy and laparoscopic right colectomy for right colon tumor
    Quan Li Zhu, Xin Xu, Zhi Jian Pan
    Medicine.2021; 100(33): e27002.     CrossRef
  • Safety with Innovation in Colon and Rectal Robotic Surgery
    Deborah S. Keller, Christina N. Jenkins
    Clinics in Colon and Rectal Surgery.2021; 34(05): 273.     CrossRef
  • Robotic and robotic-assisted vs laparoscopic rectal cancer surgery: A meta-analysis of short-term and long-term results
    Guojun Tong, Guiyang Zhang, Zhaozheng Zheng
    Asian Journal of Surgery.2021;[Epub]     CrossRef
  • Robotic versus laparoscopic colorectal surgery in elderly patients in terms of recovery time: a monocentric experience
    Giuseppe Palomba, Vincenza Paola Dinuzzi, Marianna Capuano, Pietro Anoldo, Marco Milone, Giovanni Domenico De Palma, Giovanni Aprea
    Journal of Robotic Surgery.2021; 16(4): 981.     CrossRef
  • Robotic surgery for colorectal disease: review of current port placement and future perspectives
    Jong Lyul Lee, Hassan A. Alsaleem, Jin Cheon Kim
    Annals of Surgical Treatment and Research.2020; 98(1): 31.     CrossRef
  • The “Micro Hand S” Robot-Assisted Versus Conventional Laparoscopic Right Colectomy: Short-Term Outcomes at a Single Center
    Yijia Zeng, Guohui Wang, Yong Liu, Zheng Li, Bo Yi, Shaihong Zhu
    Journal of Laparoendoscopic & Advanced Surgical Techniques.2020; 30(4): 363.     CrossRef
  • Robotic right colonic resection. Is the robotic third arm a game-changer?
    Alberto Mangano, Federico Gheza, Roberto Bustos, Mario Masrur, Francesco Bianco, Eduardo Fernandes, Valentina Valle, Pier C. Giulianotti
    Minerva Chirurgica.2020;[Epub]     CrossRef
  • Robotic Right Colectomy for Colon Cancer; Two Case Reports
    Ryosuke Fukuyo, Hironobu Baba, Takatoshi Matsuyama, Akifumi Kikuchi, Shinichi Yamauchi, Ayumi Takaoka, Yuriko Matsumiya, Yudai Yamamoto, Masanori Tokunaga, Yusuke Kinugasa
    The Japanese Journal of Gastroenterological Surgery.2020; 53(2): 164.     CrossRef
  • Impact of ASA-score, age and learning curve on early outcome in the initiation phase of an oncological robotic colorectal program
    Hülya Sarikaya, Tahar Benhidjeb, Sergiu I. Iosivan, Theodoros Kolokotronis, Christine Förster, Stephan Eckert, Ludwig Wilkens, Alaa Nasser, Sebastian Rehberg, Martin Krüger, Jan Schulte am Esch
    Scientific Reports.2020;[Epub]     CrossRef
  • Robotic or laparoscopic surgery for rectal cancer - which is the best answer? a comprehensive review of non-oncological outcomes and learning curve
    Sandra L. Kavalukas, Amandeep Ghuman, Stephen P. Sharp, Steven D. Wexner
    Mini-invasive Surgery.2020;[Epub]     CrossRef
  • Right hemicolectomy: a network meta-analysis comparing open, laparoscopic-assisted, total laparoscopic, and robotic approach
    Emanuele Rausa, Michael Eamon Kelly, Emanuele Asti, Alberto Aiolfi, Gianluca Bonitta, Luigi Bonavina
    Surgical Endoscopy.2019; 33(4): 1020.     CrossRef
  • Long-term oncologic after robotic versus laparoscopic right colectomy: a prospective randomized study
    Jun Seok Park, Hyun Kang, Soo Yeun Park, Hye Jin Kim, In Teak Woo, In-Kyu Park, Gyu-Seog Choi
    Surgical Endoscopy.2019; 33(9): 2975.     CrossRef
  • Robotic Versus Conventional Laparoscopic Surgery for Colorectal Cancer: A Systematic Review and Meta‐Analysis with Trial Sequential Analysis
    Ka Ting Ng, Azlan Kok Vui Tsia, Vanessa Yu Ling Chong
    World Journal of Surgery.2019; 43(4): 1146.     CrossRef
  • A standardized suprapubic bottom-to-up approach in robotic right colectomy: technical and oncological advances for complete mesocolic excision (CME)
    Jan Schulte am Esch, Sergio-I. Iosivan, Fabian Steinfurth, Ammar Mahdi, Christine Förster, Ludwig Wilkens, Alaa Nasser, Hülya Sarikaya, Tahar Benhidjeb, Martin Krüger
    BMC Surgery.2019;[Epub]     CrossRef
  • Robotic versus laparoscopic right colectomy: an updated systematic review and meta-analysis
    Leonardo Solaini, Francesca Bazzocchi, Davide Cavaliere, Andrea Avanzolini, Alessandro Cucchetti, Giorgio Ercolani
    Surgical Endoscopy.2018; 32(3): 1104.     CrossRef
  • Short-Term Outcomes with Robotic Right Colectomy
    Scott R. Kelley, Emilie Duchalais, David W. Larson
    The American Surgeon™.2018; 84(11): 1768.     CrossRef
  • Robot-Assisted Colectomy for Left-Sided Colon Cancer: Comparison of Reduced-Port and Conventional Multi-Port Robotic Surgery
    Sung Uk Bae, Woon Kyung Jeong, Seong Kyu Baek
    Journal of Laparoendoscopic & Advanced Surgical Techniques.2017; 27(4): 398.     CrossRef
  • Colorectal surgery in elderly patients: our experience with DaVinci Xi® System
    A. Oldani, P. Bellora, M. Monni, B. Amato, S. Gentilli
    Aging Clinical and Experimental Research.2017; 29(S1): 91.     CrossRef
  • Robot-assisted versus laparoscopic-assisted surgery for colorectal cancer: a meta-analysis
    Xuan Zhang, ZhengQiang Wei, MengJun Bie, XuDong Peng, Cheng Chen
    Surgical Endoscopy.2016; 30(12): 5601.     CrossRef
  • Robotic versus laparoscopic low anterior resection for rectal cancer: a meta-analysis
    Yanlai Sun, Huirong Xu, Zengjun Li, Jianjun Han, Wentao Song, Junwei Wang, Zhongfa Xu
    World Journal of Surgical Oncology.2016;[Epub]     CrossRef
  • Comparison of perioperative and short-term outcomes between robotic and conventional laparoscopic surgery for colonic cancer: a systematic review and meta-analysis
    Sungwon Lim, Jin Hee Kim, Se-Jin Baek, Seon-Hahn Kim, Seon Heui Lee
    Annals of Surgical Treatment and Research.2016; 90(6): 328.     CrossRef
  • Laparoscopic and robot-assisted laparoscopic digestive surgery: Present and future directions
    Juan C Rodríguez-Sanjuán
    World Journal of Gastroenterology.2016; 22(6): 1975.     CrossRef
  • Effect of BMI on Short-Term Outcomes with Robotic-Assisted Laparoscopic Surgery: a Case-Matched Study
    Deborah S. Keller, Nisreen Madhoun, Juan Ramon Flores-Gonzalez, Sergio Ibarra, Reena Tahilramani, Eric M. Haas
    Journal of Gastrointestinal Surgery.2016; 20(3): 488.     CrossRef
  • Robotic single docking total colectomy for ulcerative colitis: First experience with a novel technique
    Franco Roviello, Riccardo Piagnerelli, Francesco Ferrara, Maximilian Scheiterle, Lorenzo De Franco, Daniele Marrelli
    International Journal of Surgery.2015; 21: 63.     CrossRef
  • Is robot-assisted laparoscopic right colectomy more effective than the conventional laparoscopic procedure? A meta-analysis of short-term outcomes
    Fabio Rondelli, Ruben Balzarotti, Fabio Villa, Adriano Guerra, Nicola Avenia, Enrico Mariani, Walter Bugiantella
    International Journal of Surgery.2015; 18: 75.     CrossRef
  • Robotic colonic resection
    Emmanouil P. Pappou, Martin R. Weiser
    Journal of Surgical Oncology.2015; 112(3): 315.     CrossRef
  • European association of endoscopic surgeons (EAES) consensus statement on the use of robotics in general surgery
    Amir Szold, Roberto Bergamaschi, Ivo Broeders, Jenny Dankelman, Antonello Forgione, Thomas Langø, Andreas Melzer, Yoav Mintz, Salvador Morales-Conde, Michael Rhodes, Richard Satava, Chung-Ngai Tang, Ramon Vilallonga
    Surgical Endoscopy.2015; 29(2): 253.     CrossRef
  • Robotic versus conventional laparoscopic surgery for rectal cancer: systematic review and meta-analysis
    Seon Heui Lee, Sungwon Lim, Jin Hee Kim, Kil Yeon Lee
    Annals of Surgical Treatment and Research.2015; 89(4): 190.     CrossRef
  • Robot-assisted single-incision total colectomy: a case report
    Yen-Yi Juo, Vincent Obias
    The International Journal of Medical Robotics and Computer Assisted Surgery.2015; 11(1): 104.     CrossRef
  • Robotic versus laparoscopic surgery for colonic disease: a meta-analysis of postoperative variables
    Alberto Zarak, Alvaro Castillo, Kandace Kichler, Lucy de la Cruz, Leonardo Tamariz, Srinivas Kaza
    Surgical Endoscopy.2015; 29(6): 1341.     CrossRef
  • Outcomes of Robotic-Assisted Colorectal Surgery Compared with Laparoscopic and Open Surgery: a Systematic Review
    Chang Woo Kim, Chang Hee Kim, Seung Hyuk Baik
    Journal of Gastrointestinal Surgery.2014; 18(4): 816.     CrossRef
  • Robotic Surgery for Colorectal Cancer
    Ioannis G. Papanikolaou
    Surgical Laparoscopy, Endoscopy & Percutaneous Techniques.2014; 24(6): 478.     CrossRef
  • Robotic versus laparoscopic right colectomy: a meta-analysis
    Huirong Xu, Jianning Li, Yanlai Sun, Zengjun Li, Yanan Zhen, Bin Wang, Zhongfa Xu
    World Journal of Surgical Oncology.2014; 12(1): 274.     CrossRef
  • Outcomes and Costs Associated With Robotic Colectomy in the Minimally Invasive Era
    Joshua A. Tyler, Justin P. Fox, Mayur M. Desai, W. Brian Perry, Sean C. Glasgow
    Diseases of the Colon & Rectum.2013; 56(4): 458.     CrossRef
  • Robotic Colonic Surgery
    Andrew Kai-Yip Fung, Emad H. Aly
    Diseases of the Colon & Rectum.2013; 56(6): 786.     CrossRef
  • Lap Colectomy and Robotics for Colon Cancer
    Eduardo Parra-Davila, Sonia Ramamoorthy
    Surgical Oncology Clinics of North America.2013; 22(1): 143.     CrossRef
  • FirstFirst
  • PrevPrev
  • Page of 1
  • Next Next
  • Last Last

Ann Coloproctol : Annals of Coloproctology Twitter Facebook
TOP